Duel of the plates: is Malaysia’s or Singapore’s better?

Duel of the plates: is Malaysia’s or Singapore’s better?

Despite some similarities, Malaysian and Singaporean hawker food have clear distinctions that set them apart.

Nasi lemak and laksa are among the favourite hawker fare favoured by both Malaysians and Singaporeans.
PETALING JAYA:
The relationship between Malaysia and Singapore goes way back and it can be aptly described as an amicable one.

Malaysians and Singaporeans often have relatives living across the Tebrau Strait, and thousands cross the border in their daily commute to work.

In addition, it is quite common to see gaggles of Singaporeans thronging Malaysian food havens like Melaka, Ipoh and George Town in search of hawker fare.

But here is when the friendship turns into full-blown rivalry, comparable to that of England and France.

While both countries have a shared history and culture, food is a prickly topic, with both claiming culinary superiority.

In fact, both countries have claimed ownership of the same dish, with internet users exchanging verbal blows in online spaces.

But how different is Singaporean food from Malaysian food? And can Malaysia finally claim a win over Singapore? (Please?)

Let’s take a look at what sets the cuisines of the two countries apart:

1. Nasi lemak

Beloved by Malaysians and Singaporeans, the battle about the origins of nasi lemak is still raging.

It’s arguably the national dish of Malaysia, beloved for its versatility and sheer inability to disappoint anyone who tastes it.

For most folks, the perfect nasi lemak requires just a few components; namely the coconut milk rice, a hardboiled egg, fried anchovies, cucumber slices, peanuts and sambal wrapped up with a banana leaf.

These days however, most hawkers also offer side dishes of chicken rendang, squid sambal, fried fish and vegetables.

In Singapore, their take on nasi lemak is roughly the same as Malaysia’s, though a popular variant involves colouring the rice green with pandan leaf juice.

It’s also common to see certain side dishes one would rarely see in Malaysia, including fish cake, otak-otak and luncheon meat.

2. Bak kut teh (non-halal)

While Malaysian bak kut teh focuses on herbs, Singaporean bak kut teh has an emphasis on garlic and pepper. (KY Speaks pic)

No one will ever know if the first bowl of bak kut teh was cooked in Malaysia or Singapore, but one thing’s for certain – both countries have a unique spin on it.

A popular breakfast for the Chinese community in both countries, Klang has earned quite a reputation for serving the best-tasting bak kut teh in Malaysia.

The delicious-smelling broth is created by simmering pork bones and meat for hours, after which spare ribs and tofu are added to the broth.

In Malaysia, the broth has a distinct herbal aroma and taste, thanks to the use of dried spices and medicinal herbs.

On the other side of the border though, white pepper and garlic dominate the broth, making it a rather heaty but tasty affair.

3. Laksa

Singapore laksa is also known as Katong laksa, supposedly because of a famous laksa hawker in the Katong district. (Moganraj Villavan @ FMT Lifestyle)

Laksa is a particularly popular dish in both countries and in fact, it has been at the centre of a diplomatic and cultural dispute!

In 2009, Malaysia attempted to claim ownership of laksa, which resulted in a substantial pushback from Singapore.

Given the sheer number of laksa variants, it is best to just focus on what makes Singapore laksa distinct from its counterparts.

Singapore laksa is often said to have a certain sandy texture to its gravy, largely because of the abundance of dried prawns used.

Also called Katong laksa, Singapore laksa is characterised as being sweeter, with thick rice noodles served with a boiled egg.

4. Char kway teow

In Malaysia, char kway teow uses only flat noodles, whereas Singaporean variants tend to mix flat noodles with egg noodles. (KY Speaks pic)

It’s every dietitian’s nightmare, but it’s also a favourite among foodies in Malaysia and Singapore; it’s char kway teow.

Originally served as a cheap high-energy meal for coolies working at the docks, char kway teow has since secured its position as a must-have in any respectable hawker centre.

On both sides of the Tebrau Strait, char kway teow features flat rice noodles stir-fried with a mixture of prawns, bean sprouts, eggs and cockles.

However, in Malaysia, it is sacrilege to have any other kind of noodles aside from the traditional flat noodles.

In Singapore, flat noodles are mixed with thin egg noodles when ordering char kway teow, with the occasional addition of a sweet sauce.

5. Ais kacang

The list of ingredients in a typical bowl of ais kacang in Malaysia is rather extensive compared to Singapore.

This shaved ice dessert is popular in both countries – and that’s where the similarity ends. What’s placed on the pile of shaved ice is what distinguishes Malaysian ais kacang from its Singaporean sibling.

Malaysian ais kacang tends to feature many more ingredients, with red beans, kidney beans, grass jelly, corn and ice-cream being common.

In Singapore, it is normal to see the ice being drizzled with a multicoloured syrup, with most of the tasty toppings hiding at the bottom of the bowl rather than sprinkled over the ice.

Stay current - Follow FMT on WhatsApp, Google news and Telegram

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.