Think tank gets leave to challenge rejection of Quranic text translation

Think tank gets leave to challenge rejection of Quranic text translation

The Islamic Renaissance Front says it was not given reasons or the opportunity to be heard before a 2023 conditional approval was revoked.

Mahkamah KL
The Kuala Lumpur High Court has granted the Islamic Renaissance Front leave to pursue its judicial review application against the home ministry and the Quran control and licensing of printing board.
KUALA LUMPUR:
The High Court is set to hear a legal challenge brought by the Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF) over the home ministry’s refusal to certify the translation of a Quranic commentary from English into Bahasa Melayu.

The subject text, “The Message of the Qur’an”, was translated and explained in English by Muhammad Asad, and first published in Gibraltar in 1980.

The English version has been published and distributed in Malaysia since 2011, with the government’s approval.

Justice Amarjeet Singh granted IRF leave today after senior federal counsel Faisal Noor told the court that the attorney-general had no objection to the judicial review application being heard on its merits.

The court fixed July 24 for case management.

IRF was represented by lawyer Surendra Ananth.

It named the home ministry and the Quran control and licensing of printing board as respondents in its application.

On Nov 2, 2023, the home ministry granted conditional approval to IRF to undertake a translation of the subject work into Bahasa Melayu.

Among the conditions was that the translated text could only be used for academic purposes. IRF was also required to make certain corrections to the Bahasa Melayu version of the text.

IRF claims that it fulfilled those requirements.

However, on Feb 21, the home ministry said it was revoking the conditional approval, claiming that the final copy of the translated work failed to meet the “required standards” for certification.

IRF claimed that it was not given reasons for the government’s “U-turn” on its 2023 approval.

It also said the ministry had denied it the opportunity to be heard.

“This approval cannot be arbitrarily revoked without proper reasons,” it said.

IRF is also seeking damages, and a declaration that the Nov 2, 2023 approval is valid.

Stay current - Follow FMT on WhatsApp, Google news and Telegram

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.