Penang assembly appoints new appeals board chief after controversy

Penang assembly appoints new appeals board chief after controversy

Deputy chief minister Jagdeep Singh Deo says he was transparent when he first nominated his father-in-law for the post.

Jagdeep Singh Deo
Jagdeep Singh Deo told the Penang state assembly that new appeals board chairman K Kumaraendran is an experienced and senior lawyer.
GEORGE TOWN:
The state assembly has replaced lawyer Baldev Gurchan Singh with senior lawyer K Kumaraendran as the chairman of the appeals board under the state Freedom of Information Enactment 2010.

This follows allegations of nepotism that led to Baldev, the father-in-law of deputy chief minister Jagdeep Singh Deo, declining the position.

Kumaraendran now leads the six-member board, with former Bar Council president Fareed Gafoor retained as deputy chairman.

Jagdeep said Kumaraendran was selected as chairman due to his calibre and seniority.

Lawyer K Simon Murali was also selected as a new board member, replacing Harinder Malkit Singh.

Penang Bar chairman Carolyn Oh, Nagarethinam Rengasamy Pillai and Regina Amalorpava Mary Aboorvasamy are the other board members.

In moving a motion on appointments to the board, Jagdeep defended Baldev’s original nomination as chairman, citing his decades of experience as a lawyer in Penang.

“Baldev is the longest-serving and most senior lawyer in Penang. He has been a lawyer for (58) years. His appointment was based on his experience, and there was no issue for me,” he said.

“But he is my father-in-law, and I disclosed that in front of all of you (when he nominated Baldev at the last assembly meeting). Some parties claimed I did not disclose this outside the Dewan, but it was done here, it was clear. There is no issue for me.

“He is a senior lawyer, but he said, ‘I don’t need this.’ This is charity work, and he will not receive a single sen. This work is for the rakyat.

“Then I looked for another capable lawyer. Kumaraendran was a close friend of my late father. If you want to say there is a conflict of interest, what do you want me to do? He is an experienced and qualified lawyer.”

Responding to opposition members who asked why Baldev was replaced, Jagdeep said: “He himself chose to step down, and there is no problem with that.”

The motion to update the members was supported by executive councillor Daniel Gooi.

Urimai secretary-general Satees Muniandy had, among others, criticised Baldev’s initial appointment, questioning the transparency and fairness of the process.

Stay current - Follow FMT on WhatsApp, Google news and Telegram

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.