Despite soaring beef prices as the US cattle population hit a 75-year low, farmers like Stem are feeling the squeeze from steeper business costs, budget-conscious consumers and President Donald Trump’s trade policy.
“The cost of doing business is almost outpricing (our ability) to continue to raise cattle,” Stem told AFP.
“From cutting hay to feeding the cattle to maintaining equipment, maintaining staff, feed, everything has gone up,” he said. “When does that stabilise and stop?”
Trump’s latest move to boost Argentine beef imports is adding to concerns, vexing a key support base of the Republican president as midterm elections approach.
Stem, 40, has a herd of around 250 cattle in Ashland, Virginia.
Most are sold at larger markets where they are purchased and fed to slaughter weight, while around 15% are processed nearby and sold at Stem’s butcher shop.
For him, higher beef prices have been a double-edged sword.
His revenue from selling cattle has risen, but so have operational costs.
And there are limits to how much he can hike consumer prices at his shop to make up the margins.
“They will only spend so much on a cut of beef, especially when you have imported meats that you can purchase for 50% to 60% less at a larger store,” Stem said.
Already, ribeye that sold for US$14.99 a pound in 2019 now sells for US$32.99, he said. His customer sales have dropped by 30%.
To afford the property, he has diversified operations at Oakdale into winemaking and hosting events like weddings.
‘State of crisis’
Steeper beef prices have become a symbol of high living costs in the world’s biggest economy, which has fuelled voter frustration. Last fall, Trump demanded that ranchers slash their prices.
Trump has since exempted Brazilian beef from sharp tariffs and moved this month to expand imports of trimmings from Argentina to cool ground beef prices.
Yet, officials predict costs will keep creeping up.
Beef and veal prices were up 15% year-on-year in January, while ground beef prices, which hit a new high in December, have continued climbing.
Costs will likely stay elevated as consumer demand remains robust, while it takes years to rebuild American herds depleted by drought and import restrictions over a parasite.
Meanwhile, American farmers and ranchers fear Trump’s policies will undercut their production and profits.
“We do need to feed the people of the United States,” said Stem. “But we’re opening a door that’s going to, I think, significantly harm farmers.”
“I’m a supporter of the Republican administration,” he added. “I’m not a supporter of the unknowns that we get right now.”
The Ranchers Cattlemen Action Legal Fund United Stockgrowers of America warned recently: “Our industry is in a state of crisis and needs protection against price-depressing imports.”
Iowa farmer Lance Lillibridge told AFP that cattle producers have been “living off very skinny margins” for years.
“People are getting tired of working this hard for nothing,” he added. “Right now, our cattle prices are exactly where they should be.”
‘Cut back’
But households are feeling the pinch.
Endawnson Nungo, 56, a South Carolinian in the railroad industry, told AFP “we’ve cut back a lot” due to beef prices.
At a butcher shop in Washington, scientist Caleb Svezia, 28, said he started noticing higher meat prices around six months ago.
He has cut back on snacks when grocery shopping to save up for better quality meats.
Jamie Stachowski, who runs Stachowski’s Market, said customers have pulled back. Like Stem, he has had to raise prices, lifting them by 30% over the past year.
In turn, his sales dropped by 15%.
Some consumers also pivoted from prime cuts to secondary ones – or bought other meats altogether.
“The beef industry is billions and billions of dollars,” he said. “Yet everybody just makes pennies on the pound.”